We had ordered the bread sticks with pizza sauce and garlic butter for dipping. You can order it with nacho cheese sauce, but we passed on that. We all really liked the bread sticks, but thought they could have been a bit more garlicky, but that is coming from a group of garlic lovers.
We preferred the pizza sauce over the garlic butter sauce. H thought at first the garlic butter sauce tasted a bit like mayonnaise. Unfortunately after further tasting it, she noticed a clump of flour in the bottom. This was definitely not a pleasant addition, but we decided to let it slide since the breadsticks were so good and thought of it as a positive proving that their food is homemade.
L, our pepperoni lover, had us order a pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese.
We all really liked their sauce. I personally thought the pizza was cooked perfectly since the bottom was not black or loaded with flour, it didn't taste like cardboard to me like another popular pizza place in town does. However, H prefers her crust to be crispier and likes the cardboard taste of the other place.
Overall, we gave the pizza a 7 out of 10. We all decided that we'd order from Lake Placid Pizza Co. again and help keep the back space of the building in business.